Just some stuff about photography


Dimage Scan MultiPro Micro-banding

The “thin red line” problem, and a solution

in Scanning , Saturday, July 23, 2011

After 10 years or so of pretty constant use, I’m beginning to get the hang of my Minolta MultiPro film scanner. Having very belatedly discovered Scanhancer inventor Erik de Goederen’s tip for making a single-sided glass film holder, I’m also getting something close to dust-free scans. So naturally, now was the time for the Minolta to blow a gasket.

Well, fortunately it seems to be a fairly minor gasket, and in fact I may be lucky to have only been hit by it now, because it has a name in the MultiPro community: micro-banding. Somebody even built a Photoshop plug-in (Windows only) to fix it, way back. Actually I think it is more of a stuck pixel, or whatever passes for that, as the effect is of a single-pixel wide red line right across the scan. It is strange that it’s always red though.

Multipro red line red channel

the red line, aka “micro banding”

The fix is actually pretty simple, so you don’t need a plug-in. Before you do any other editing - and especially rotating - simply zoom in at 100% and select a thin rectangle, say 5 pixels high, all the way across the image, with the red line centered. Then select the red channel only. Then apply the Dust & Scratch filter with settings Radius 2, Threshold 2 or thereabouts.

Multipro red line red channel

red channel only

Multipro red line red channel

Dust & Scratch filter settings

It doesn’t completely go away, but you’re never going to see it at anything less than serious pixel-peeping level, and certainly not on a print.

I don’t know why it hit my scanner now. Could be old age. Could be dust, although I’ve opened it up for the first time ever, and it is remarkably clean inside. Could be because I’ve been fiddling around with fluid mounts. I don’t know, I just hope it doesn’t spread, because there’s essentially nothing available to replace it.


Posted in category "Scanning" on Saturday, July 23, 2011 at 08:02 PM

Older Comments

from Project Hyakumeizan on Tue, July 26, 2011 - 9:29

Nothing to replace it? Well, today, in a fit on insane optimism, I ordered a Plustek 7600 (with Silverfast AI). Will let you know if/how it works….

from david mantripp on Tue, July 26, 2011 - 9:41

I’m sure it will work fine. But you’d have to fold a 6x7 slide to get it in and I’m not sure that would have quite the desired effect - although it might go down well on Flickr. As for XPan, well, nope.

from Project Hyakumeizan on Thu, August 25, 2011 - 8:56

(A few weeks later): yes, the Plustek works fine, straight out of the box. Next I’ll try folding medium-format film into it, as you suggested. I’m sure Silverfast Studio will be able to handle it: isn’t that what Multi-Exposure is for ...?